Stanley Fish Praises the NAS’s Sustainability Report

National Association of Scholars

The eminent literary critic and legal scholar Stanley Fish has read and commented on the National Association of Scholars’ study, Sustainability: Higher Education’s New FundamentalismThis is a matter of some moment for NAS. Twenty-five years ago when NAS was a fledgling organization, Fish criticized us harshly, and his characterizations remain in circulation to this day.  

Fish has always been a man of surprises, but his positive words about our new study will be especially surprising to many in the academy. Fish praised “the report's comprehensiveness, clarity and tone,” while taking care to say that he stands with the majority view on “climate change.”

The NAS takes no position on climate change. The NAS study does, however, call for a more open debate on campus that includes skeptics of the catastrophic anthropogenic global warming hypothesis. 

Fish’s statement in full: 

I have now read the NAS report on climate change and the sustainability movement on campus and my response to it is somewhat complicated. First, let me congratulate you on the report's comprehensiveness, clarity and tone. You never descend to the hectoring and bullying that characterize debate on these issues. You lay out the case in great detail and you anticipate and respond to the objections you imagine issuing from some of those whose positions you oppose.

Moreover your treatment of those "on the other side" is always respectful even when you report arguments and actions you find distressing.

Now for the other shoe. I remain persuaded by those who argue both for climate change and for the human contribution to it. I know that you challenge the "97% of scientists" claim and I know too that often in the past minority positions in science have turned out to be correct in the long run.

But I stand with Judith Jarvis Thompson when she insists (along with Thomas Kuhn) that in the short run we have to go with the preponderance of disciplinary wisdom and so I cannot agree that the issues are not settled. I think they are but I also think that they could possibly be unsettled in the future; that possibility, merely theoretical, is not one, however, that should weigh on academic/scientific judgment.

On the other matter--the adoption by some colleges and universities of a sustainability agenda as an academic orthodoxy from which one is not allowed to deviate—I am in agreement with you, as you might have expected me to be. Here my position is exactly that of President Faust of Harvard: the business of the academy is the advancement of knowledge not the advancement of social or environmental justice. I wish I had seen your report before completing Versions of Academic Freedom.

We are grateful for Professor Fish’s generous assessment of the report. No doubt we will continue to disagree about many things, but in an era marked more and more by rancorous polarization on campus and unwillingness to see any merit in views that deviate from campus orthodoxy, Fish’s “somewhat complicated” response to our report is exemplary. And we are grateful that he has been willing to let us put it on the record.

Image: UConn Today

  • Share

Most Commented

October 29, 2024

1.

The Looming Irrelevance of Middle East Study Centers

Today’s Middle Eastern Studies Centers are facing a crisis due to the winds of change in the Middle East and their own ideological echo chamber....

November 19, 2024

2.

Lee Zeldin Should Reform EPA Science Policy

NAS welcomes the nomination of Congressmen Lee Zeldin to lead the Environmental Protection Agency....

November 20, 2024

3.

NAS Welcomes Administrator McMahon's Nomination to Serve as Education Secretary

With McMahon, the new administration has a chance to drastically slim down and depoliticize the Education Department....

Most Read

May 15, 2015

1.

Where Did We Get the Idea That Only White People Can Be Racist?

A look at the double standard that has arisen regarding racism, illustrated recently by the reaction to a black professor's biased comments on Twitter....

October 12, 2010

2.

Ask a Scholar: What is the True Definition of Latino?

What does it mean to be Latino? Are only Latin American people Latino, or does the term apply to anyone whose language derived from Latin?...

May 26, 2010

3.

10 Reasons Not to Go to College

A sampling of arguments for the idea that college may not be for everyone....